Sunday, May 01, 2016

Narrative Approach to Family Counseling

Family Counseling Approach: Narrative Therapy
            Life is little less than a story, with characters and circumstances far more exquisite and complex than the most excellent writer could imagine. It is in these stories that meaning to a person’s life can be found. Narrative therapy is an approach that utilizes those stories, and new ways of looking at them in order to change the way the story ends. Narrative therapists have the beautiful gift of turning victim into heroin and tragedy into victory. Narrative therapy attempts to separate the person or family from the problem. It is based on the idea that a person’s identity is formed by our experiences. Problems are considered separate, something that a client has, not a definition of that client. While there are some similarities with traditional models of therapy, narrative therapy is profoundly different as it utilizes new ideas, assumptions, aims and methods. This approach takes a positive assumption that people are the experts in their lives, with “many skills, competencies, beliefs, values, commitments, and abilities that will assist them to reduce the influence of the problems in their lives” (Morgan,2000).
History and Philosophical Assumptions
Narrative therapy evolved out of the desire to work with individuals and families in a way that did not blame or pathologize clients (Freedman & Combs, 1996). As therapist explored new ways of working with clients, they found that families did not need to be described as “homeostatic systems, but as generative social systems with the ability to change their own lives” (Freeman & Couchonnal, 2006).  Narrative therapy was created by White and Epston based on Michael Foucault’s philosophy that “reality exists only in agreed-upon reality created between people” (Jones &Butman, 2011, p. 369).
Narrative therapy assumes that a person’s functioning is determined by the stories that families “emphasize and repeat” which create a language-based structure of “self understanding” (p.369). Thoughts become words, words become actions, and actions become character. Narrative therapy is considered a postmodern view of therapy as it posits that there are multiple realities based on each individual’s experiences, and that everything known is possible through the language (Yarhouse & Sells, 2008).
Language and how it shapes problem perceptions and definitions is vital in narrative therapy. The way in which a family tells their stories dictates how the problem affects them. Rather than see the family as problematic, the narrative therapist externalizes the problem and educates the family on how the problem has been oppressing them. By using metaphors and restructuring, the therapist helps the clients to notice their own expert knowledge and re-author their story with empowered stories (Rasheed, Rasheed, & Marley, 2010).
Narrative therapists assume that problems are located in contexts and relationships, not people (Papp, 2000). Culture and history help to shape the meanings people make about their lives; people are the meaning makers, not merely victims of circumstance without the power to change things. The people around a person attribute meaning to their life. Narratives become the frame in which a person views their world. For example, a person who feels hopeless will create a hopeless framework from which they view the world, thus making the world hopeless. When clients come into counseling, they tell stories which shape their reality and reveal the feelings and beliefs they hold about themselves and the world around them, narrative therapists pay particular attention to these stories. Narrative therapists listen not only to what the client says, but parts of the story that are not told. Most stories are originally told in a thin manner, devoid of the complexities of life. These stories ignore contradictions to the running themes of the person’s life, which are often created by others. Once a person has accepted these thin descriptions, it becomes easy for them to find supporting evidence for their story. It is the narrative therapists job to thicken the story by introducing those components left out in the original thin story. (Freedman & Combs, 1996; Papp, 2000).
Narrative Therapy in Action
Narrative therapist utilizes a respectful, non-blaming approach that centers the client as the expert in his or her own life. Narrative therapy involves structured interventions designed to help the client co-author new less problem-saturated stories (Gehart, 2010). Narrative therapy is the process of telling a story, deconstructing it, and reconstructing it in a way that provides new possibilities. The narrative therapist is seen as a collaborator in the therapeutic process instead of and expert as in other therapies. Their primary role is to assist in retelling the stories in a way that reduces the problem saturated nature of the original story. Narrative therapists are curious, always asking questions in an attempt to bring the family along a journey but do not stipulate that there is a right or wrong way to go. (Jones & Butman, 2011).
Narrative therapists have “well defined sets of questions and strategies for helping clients enact preferred narratives” (Gehart, 2010, p.403). A narrative therapist helps the client to evaluate and change their relationship to the problem. They pose questions, which help to externalize the problem thus making it less intimidating to overcome.
Narrative therapy posits that individuals interpret their lives though narratives. There is not a specific process or way in which a client’s story should be told. According to White (1995) there is:
a progression taking place in narrative therapy, and the principles that surface and play a role are not a linear, structured development of argument. In the counseling process, the therapist should be guided by and explore each client's unique story.
Practitioners of narrative therapy believe that through rearticulating family narratives and identifying the meaning attached to them, it is possible to change the story.
The techniques in narrative therapy are utilized to help separate the client from the problem. Separating the problem and person or family allows the counselor to objectify sensitive issues and dissipate defense mechanisms and resistance. By helping family members separate themselves from the problem, “externalization opens up possibilities for them to describe themselves, each other, and their relationships from a new non problem saturated perspective” (White and Epston, 1990, p.39). In essence, narrative family helps to create an alternative, more attractive family story.
            Externalizing the problem has multiple benefits. It decreases unproductive conflict, undermines the sense of failure that has developed, paves the way for family cooperation and opens up new possibilities for family members to rescue their relationship from the problem (White and Epston, 1990).
            Another vital component of narrative therapy is the utilization of exceptions. Exceptions are times in which the thinly described theme of the clients Many times when clients enter therapy they have reached a point of desperation where they are unable to see when and how things could ever be better. They have a very thin view of life and the possibilities it holds. The narrative therapists are tasked with helping the client to thicken the story, to see beyond the current circumstances to times in which they successfully navigated their circumstances. (Carr, 1998).
How Narrative Therapy is Similar/Dissimilar to Traditional Treatment
Narrative therapy differs greatly from other forms of therapy. Aside from the fact that the counselor is seen as a collaborator instead of an expert, narrative therapy also sees “the family through multiple storylines, all of which have legitimacy and must be reconciled with the other family story lines” (Yarhouse & Sells, 2008, p.271).
Narrative therapy takes an optimistic approach to clients, focusing on client strengths and abilities rather than the problems that brought them into counseling as is often the case with traditional forms of therapy (Gehart, 2010). The counselor is not interested in identifying problems but rather, focused on “conversations produced by numerous possible narratives that coincide with each family members perspective” (Miller & Forrest, 2009).
There are portions of narrative therapy that are similar and consistent with previous forms of therapy. Both person centered therapy and narrative therapy encourage knowledge and skills to be recognized and transformative. Cognitive approaches and narrative therapy recognize the effect of illogical thinking and it’s effect on the client. Narrative therapy and solution focused brief therapy both utilize the technique of identifying exceptions to the problem and using them as a basis for potential to change. (Payne, 2006).
What have I learned?
Narrative therapy is a process of story telling. The narrative therapist can empower the client to tell their story in a way changes their victim status to one capable of creating the kind of life they want. Change is possible. Narrative therapists have the unique ability to show hope in a black and white context. They do not focus on the past or the problem but on the opportunity to be different. This is something that has proven profoundly helpful in this writer’s life as the parent to a child with severe mental illness. She was adopted out of the foster care system and suffers from a multitude of severe issues. In fact, this particular paper will be submitted late as the day has been spent arguing with the behavioral health MCO and her providers trying to get her to continue to receive care in a residential treatment facility. Early in the afternoon, this writer was advised that the child needed to be picked up out of state several hours away and has spent the evening driving instead of finishing the paper. While it has been incredibly frustrating and has the potential for hopelessness to reign supreme, applying narrative therapy principles has enabled this writer to understand that this is just a part of the story, that the current circumstances can be told and rewritten in a way that allows for hope and potential. That is not something that this writer had before.
The bottom line is that successful narrative therapy is based on the concept that the individual is the expert, they are vital to the determining the direction of therapy and what is important to them (Wark, 2012). In this writer’s case, there are multiple individuals and agencies involved who have different priorities. The insurance company is trying to prevent spending money. The hospitals and counselors are trying to limit their liability for failing her. This writer is simply trying to be the heroin in a story full of monsters which seem most times to be within moments of stealing the life of her child. If this writer has learning nothing else, it is that regardless of the characters and circumstances, the story can be changed.
Christian Worldview Critique and Integration
Since there is no set standard for health, the dominant culture can influence how a family sees itself. Truth is relative which is a distinct contradiction of Christianity (Yarhouse & Sells, 2008). The primary problem with postmodern therapy and narrative therapy is that it posits that truth is relative. Human interpretation is fallible because it is based on fallible human beings. Culture and experience create a frame
As a Christian, it is vital that all ideas and concepts are filtered thoroughly through God’s word and that the principles within that word are applied. “I am the Alpha and the Omega,’ says the Lord God, ‘who is, and who was, and who is to come, the Almighty’” (Revelation 1:8). Any concept or thought, every story, no matter how firmly believed, or how well proven much be fileted through God’s Word. Our value is priceless, “For you know that it was not with perishable things such as silver or gold that you were redeemed…but with the precious blood of Christ, a lamb without blemish or defect” (1 Peter, 1990, 1:18, 19). With this in mind, the Christian counselor understands the beauty and value of God’s work. For this reason, it is altogether fitting that one’s ministry would be seek to understand the human personality and what is necessary to maintain mental and spiritual health.
“For you created my inmost being; you knit me together in my mother’s womb. I praise you because I am fearfully and wonderfully made” (Psalms, 139: 13, 14).  Our lives begin with our earliest experiences and are deeply effected by them later. Early choices made by those in control of us, and the choices we made the survive those choices define and outline our growth. (Wilson, 2001). We have chosen to believe the thin descriptions of who we are, rather than notice those times in which there were exceptions to the story.  As adults we can choose to rewrite our mindset, to repair the damage caused to our framework with both hard work and God’s grace. A person may respond positively or negatively to the changes around them as they go through development.
Our personality begins in childhood with our most early and formidable experiences. Many theorists point to the importance of parents in the formation of personality. In particular, Wilson (2001) refers to our parents as gods as they are the ones in ultimate control of everything we know, feel, and see as children. They provide a lens from which we will forever see the world. Proverbs 19:21 states, “The human mind may devise many plans, but it is the purpose of the LORD that will be established.” Personality is the compilation of who God is, who we are, and how we allow Him to direct our steps. “The body belongs to the physical side and the spirit and soul to the personal.” (Crabb, p.88). Personality is affected by outside factors, sin nature, and influence of the Holy Spirit, feelings, will, thoughts, temporal systems, and supernatural systems (Hawkins, 2008).
Problems arise when one has a skewed view of the world around them, caused oftentimes by the initial poor construction of our self-concept. Our interpretations can be misguided. This can cause one to lack motivation, feeling that our circumstances are beyond God’s reach. “Satan’s first and foremost strategy is deception” (Anderson, 2000, p. 23). However, as Christian counselors, we know that the arm of the Lord is never too short. By changing the way in which a client’s story is told, we may revive within them the motivation necessary to make changes that will bring about spiritual and psychological health. Health is defined as people who are able to accurately see their story and possess the ability to rewrite it, regardless of the circumstances around them. Healthy persons possess dedication and perseverance, but also the understanding that, “For God did not give us a spirit of timidity, but a spirit of power, of love and of self-discipline” (2 Timothy 1:7).
While God is the center and sufficient, it is this authors opinion that He has given others the wisdom to provide treatment both in and out of the Christian arena.
Any treatment method should reflect the ability to multi-task. Multitasking requires that the counselor view, “a person’s problems from several perspectives at the same time” (Hawkins, 2006).
God and/or Godly principles must be the basis for any action or thought of both the counselor and counselee. By starting with a firm foundation of God’s word, it is then possible to build upon it, to make repairs when necessary, and to train the client to tell their story in a positive regard, regardless of circumstance. When a client learns how to tell their story understanding that God is able and with Him all things are possible, they will live in a spiritually mature and healthy manner.
The best way to combat temptation is to name Satan’s lies and hold onto God’s truth. In order to most effectively bring about change, it is essential that we get our clients to see the truth about themselves and their lives, without it all other work is meaningless and built on sand. Wilson admonishes her readers to follow Paul's guidance in 1 Corinthians 11:13 which states, “When I was a child, I talked like a child, I thought like a child, I reasoned like a child. When I became a man, I put the ways of childhood behind me” (New International Version). According to Wilson, as we become adults, we must somehow change the ideas about ourselves and the world around us that we developed due to our childhood experiences. We must put away old thinking in order to become new creatures. We must learn to tell our own story instead of accepting the story told to us by others.
By locating and identifying the misbeliefs in their lives, a person can then argue against those misbeliefs, and finally replace them with the truth. (Wilson, 2001) By recognizing who they are in God, it is possible to “be the dynamic, loving, altogether whole people God meant us to be”. (Wilson, p.182) By changing those beliefs, we are able to change the cycle of hurt and fulfill the ultimate purpose God has for our lives. By lining up counseling methods and theories with God’s word, the counselor ensures the most probable success, as God’s Word is sufficient (Adams, 1986).
As Christians, we have hope because the bottom line is that regardless of original circumstances, Romans 8:28 says, “And we know that in all things God works for the good of those who love him.” He will take whatever mess of a story we have and repair it, or show us how to repair it, if we are only willing. We can use this hope to help those we have the blessing of coming into contact with so that they might not only be healthy, but also come to be one of God’s children.
 References
Adams, J. E. (1986). How To Help People Change. Grand Rapids: Zondervan.
Carr, A. (1998). Michael white’s narrative therapy. Contemporary Family Therapy: An International Journal, 20(4), 485-503.
Crabb, L. J. Jr., (1977).  Effective Biblical Counseling: A Model for Helping Caring            
Christians Become Capable Counselors.  Grand Rapids, Michigan: Zondervan Publishing House.
Freedman, J., & Combs, G. (1996). Narrative therapy: The social construction of preferred realities. New York: W. W. Norton
Freedman, J. & Combs, G. (1996). Shifting paradigms: From systems to stories. New York, NY: Norton.
Freeman, E. M., & Couchonnal, G. (2006). Narrative and culturally based approaches in practice with families. Families in Society, 87(2), 198-208,157-158. Retrieved from http://search.proquest.com/docview/230170174?accountid=12085
Gehart, D. (2010). Mastering competencies in family therapy: Theory based assessment. Belmont, CA: Cengage Learning.
Hawkins, R. E. (Speaker). (2006). Model for guiding the counseling process. Lynchburg, VA: Liberty University.
Jones, S.L. & Butman, R.E. (2011). Modern psychotherapies: A comprehensive christian appraisal. Downers Grove, IL: IVP Academic
Miller, C.P. & Forrest, A.W. (2009). Ethics of family narrative therapy. The Family Journal, 17, 156-159.
Morgan, A. (2000). What is narrative therapy?; An easy to read introduction. Adelaide, South Australia: Dulwich Centre Publications. Retrieved from http://www.dulwichcentre.com.au/what-is-narrative-therapy.html
Papp, P. (2000). Couples on the fault line. New York, NY: The Guildford Press.
Payne, M. (2006). Narrative therapy. London, GBR: Sage Publications Inc.
Rasheed, J.M., Rasheed, M.N., & Marley, J.A. (2010). Readings in family therapy: From theory to practice. London: SAGE Publications Ltd
Wark, S. (2012). Counseling support for people with intellectual disabilities: The use of narrative therapy. The Australian Journal of Rehabilitation Counseling, 18(1), 37-49. doi:http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/jrc.2012.6
White, M. & Epston, D. (1990). Narrative means to therapeutic ends. New York, NY: W.W. Norton & Company
White, M. (1995) Re-authoring lives: Interviews and Essays. Adelaide: Dulwich Centre Publications.
Wilson, S. D.  (2001).  Hurt people hurt people: Hope and healing for yourself and your
 relationships. Grand Rapids, MI: Discovery House Publishers.
Yarhouse, M.A. & Sells, J.N. (2008). Family therapies: A comprehensive christian appraisal. Downers Grove, IL: IVP Academic


Attachment Disorder Within The Foster Care System

Attachment Disorder Within the Foster Care and Adoption System
The relationships formed in early infancy and childhood create the framework from which all future relationships will be played out. The cement that holds this framework together is called attachment. When children enter the foster care and or adoption system, the bond that was previously formed is broken. At times this occurs due to a birthparents choice to place their child for adoption, but more often this results from abuse or neglect. This abuse or neglect can lead to the development of various forms of attachment disorder. Attachment disorder is a serious psychological illness that without intervention can lead to detrimental and lifelong effects.  Children in the foster care system are at higher risk for developing this serious illness and care should be taken to not only understand the disease, but to also find ways to help treat it’s effects.
Abuse and Neglect Statistics
The numbers regarding child abuse in the United States are staggering. The National Child Abuse and Neglect Data System (NCANDS) reports that most states recognize four major types of abuse that includes: neglect, physical abuse, psychological maltreatment, and sexual abuse (Child Welfare Information Center, 2010). Neglect is a passive form of abuse in which the victim’s needs are not met by their caregiver (Goldman, Salus, Wolcott & Kennedy, 2003). Physical abuse is when physical force is used to cause harm, physical pain, injury or other bodily harm to the child (2003). Psychological abuse is also known as verbal or mental abuse and usually involves a parent behaving in a way that conveys a feeling of worthlessness to the child (2003). Sexual abuse is sexual behavior with a child that may include fondling, intercourse, rape, incest, sodomy, exhibitionism, sexual exploitation, or exposure to pornography (2003). Using this definition of abuse, they estimate that there were approximately 695 thousand new reports of abuse in 2010. Of those new reports of abuse, 78.3% suffered neglect, 17.6% suffered physical abuse, and 9.2% suffered sexual abuse. Those reports of abuse resulted in over 250 thousand children entering the foster care system, only half of which later returned home. Consistently there are about 400-500 thousand children who are in the foster care system at any given time (Child Welfare Information Center, 2010).
While the statistics show that there is a high prevalence of abuse, Johnson, 2004, points out that the numbers could be even higher as in order to be able to identify abuse, researchers and clinicians need to be able to know who and what to be looking for (Johnson, 2004). Training in recognition of the signs and symptoms of attachment disorder could help improve these numbers as they often point to a larger problem in a child’s family of origin.
According to national statistics, children who grow up in foster care face a bleak future without effective intervention. Forty to fifty percent of children in the foster care system will never complete high school. Without parents to encourage and support them, many lose interest. The other more maladaptive behaviors caused by attachment disorder lead them to thoughts and actions that constantly destroy the world around them. The statistics concerning those children who age out of foster care are even more disturbing, over 66% will be homeless, go to jail, or die within one year of leaving the foster care system (Vacca, 2007).
It seems contradictory that a child who is removed from a home of abuse or neglect would not automatically change behaviors, especially those that prove maladaptive in their new environment. In order to understand this, one must look at the nature of attachment theory.
Overview of Attachment Theory and Attachment Disorder
         In order to understand attachment disorder, one must first know what attachment is. Feldman, 2011, calls attachment the “positive emotional bond that develops between a child and a particular, special individual” (Feldman, 2011, p.179). John Bolby first explored attachment theory in the 1930’s as he studied the effects of maternal loss and a child’s later ability to form relationships (Ainsworth, 1989). Bolby believed that attachment was a biological function that allowed for an infants survival, and provided the means for protection, comfort, and support (Ainsworth, 1989). It is vital that children have a secure base from which to explore the unfamiliar world around them. Aside from this, Chapman, 2002, describes the benefit of attachment, “Attachment with a parent provides the setting in which emotional responsiveness, behavioral purposefulness, cognitive understanding and language development occur (2002).”
Attachment develops in a cyclical process. During the first few years of life an attachment cycle occurs which builds a child’s level of attachment. The attachment cycle is most commonly presented as occurring between birth and age two (Feldman, 2011). Essentially, an infant will express a need, and the manner in which that need is met determines the cycle of bonding that will occur (Ainsworth, 1989). In healthy bonding cycles, an infant expresses a need and their parent meets the need. In turn, the infant is comforted and learns that the world is a safe place and is able to trust and thus bond with the caregiver (Attachment Disorder Site, 2013).
In the disturbed attachment cycle, an infant expresses a need and that needs is met inadequately, if at all. When the need is left unmet, the infant learns that the world is not a safe place and trust does not develop. Without trust, bonding cannot occur. (Attachment Disorder Site, 2013)
This process is repeated many times over during the first years of a child’s life. In the beginning the needs are primitive but become more complex as the child gets older. In time, “the infant begins to organize these expectations internally into what Bolby has termed working models of the physical environment, attachment figures, and himself or herself” (Ainsworth, 1989).
The attachment cycle produces three types of attachment: secure, resistant, and avoidant (Ainsworth, 1989). Securely attached children have a solid base from which to explore the world around them (Ainsworth, 1989). They are confident because their caregivers have provided loving, consistent, sensitive, and responsive care in response to their needs (Inge, 1992). When a child is unsure if their needs will be met, they display a resistant attachment. This is usually related to having parents who respond inconsistently to their needs (1992). Children suffering from avoidant attachment have learned that their needs will be met with rejection (1992). When they expressed a need, their parent rejected their cry for help or attention (1992). After awhile, the child learns it is hopeless, if not dangerous to continue to express their needs.
When The Cycle is Broken
When children enter the foster care system, regardless of the reason, they experience separation from their attachment figure. Under normal circumstances a child is later comforted following the separation from their attachment figure (Conners, 2011). When children are taken from their primary caregiver, they are typically placed within a foster home or other care facility. The new caregivers may or may not be adequate, but even at their best; they are not the person who the child is attached to. A break occurs that the child cannot repair.
The break in attachment is further exacerbated by the abuse or neglect that the child experienced prior to entering care. It is therefore no coincidence that there is such a high prevalence of attachment issues within the foster care system. It is important to note that children who display insecure or disrupted attachment behaviors do not necessarily have attachment disorder (Greenburg, 1999).  However, there is a high prevalence of attachment disorder among children in the foster care system. Zeanah, Scheering, Borris, Heller, Smyke, and Trapani (2004) found that approximately 38-40% of children met the diagnosis criteria for attachment disorder (2004).
What Attachment Disordered Children Look Like
Because of the severity of what happens when children live within the foster care system, it is imperative to look at the symptoms of attachment disorder in relation to the outcomes of children within the foster care system. A child’s inability to form normal and healthy relationships leads to a host of behaviors that range from maladaptive to dangerous. Nancy Thomas, 2005, has written list of symptoms for attachment disorder in her book, When Love is Not Enough. According to her, the symptoms for attachment disorder include the following:
superficially engaging and charming, lack of eye contact on parents terms, indiscriminately affectionate with strangers, not affectionate on parents’ terms, destructive to self, others and material things, cruelty to animals, lying about the obvious, stealing, no impulse controls, learning lags, lack of cause and effect thinking, lack of conscience, abnormal eating patterns, poor peer relationships, preoccupation with fire, preoccupation with blood and gore, persistent nonsense chatter, inappropriately demanding and clingy, abnormal speech patterns, manipulative, triangulation of adults, false allegations of abuse, presumptive entitlement issues, and or, parents appear hostile and angry (p.19).
If one compares the symptoms of attachment disorder, with the known problem behaviors of children in foster care, it becomes very clear that there is a strong link between the disorder and the behaviors of these children. 
It is important to note that there has been much debate as to how and why pathogenic care affects one child and not another, as not every child who is abused or neglected develops attachment disorder. There is some evidence that “a child’s temperament and the specific neurological consequences of chronic or severe maltreatment may influence the way a child responds (Haugaard & Hazan, 2004). Some children simply fair better under pathogenic care.
Diagnosis of Attachment Disorder
Diagnosis of attachment disorder is at times difficult because there are so many comorbid conditions that appear with these children (Hall & Geher, 2003). Children with attachment disorder often end up with a list of other diagnosis that when further examined are encapsulated entirely within the attachment disorder symptom list. This is because the children fluctuate in their behaviors and behave differently depending on whom they are dealing with. One provider may see different symptoms that another provider does not ever notice (Hall & Geher, 2003). Haugaard & Hazan, 2004, also point to the fact that the list of symptoms of attachment disorder is so broad that it may at times be over diagnosed (2004).
            Specifically the DSM-IV requires that children diagnosed with RAD have histories of pathogenic care, meaning experiences of parental abuse and neglect or lack of a consistent caregiver (Hardy, 2007). Because of this, it is logical that children most affected by attachment disorders are those within the foster care system.
Intervention and treatment
Knowledge of the disorder and it’s cause can help professionals and future caregivers lesson the blow and promote healing of those attachment breaks which could lead to a lessoning of the disturbing statistics concerning life after foster care.
The first step in the treatment of attachment disorder is diagnosis. Since there is not a single, comprehensive tool for diagnosis, clinicians oftentimes utilize a variety of tools that when combined encapsulate most if not all of attachment symptoms. Sheperis, Doggett, Hoda, Blanchard, Renfro-Michel, Holdiness, & Schlagheck, 2003 recommend using several reputable assessment tools in addition to parent and child interviews, intelligence tests, and comprehensive psychological histories. The Child Behavior Checklist (CBCL) is designed to asses for abilities and behaviors in a standard format as well as differentiate between children who have and have not received mental health care in the past (2003). The Behavior Assessment System for Children (BASC) is used to assess clients for emotional and behavioral disorders (2003). The Eyberg Child Behavior Inventory (ECBI) and the Sutter-Eyberg Student Behavior Inventory are used to determine the severity of conduct related behaviors of children between the ages of 2 and 17. The Randolph Attachment Disorder Questionnaire is used to determine the severity of RAD specific symptoms, but it must be noted that it is not specific to the DSM IV criteria for attachment disorder. The Reactive Attachment Disorder Questionnaire does include the DSM-IV criteria and is used as well by Sheperis et al, 2003 in their diagnosis of attachment disorder.
Once a child is diagnosed, a treatment program must be started. The goal of attachment therapy is to give the child a “source of emotional security, opportunities for corrective social experiences, and better social skills” Haugaard & Hazan, 2004. While individual therapy is important, because attachment disorder involves their ability to make and form relationships, the relationships in the child’s life must be created and nurtured. For the child in foster care, this means helping them to learn to bond with their foster parent. There has been a great amount of controversy surrounding some types of attachment therapy, including holding therapy and rebirthing (2004). These techniques are described as “coercive” and highly criticized because they are used on children who have already experienced physical abuse (2004). A child who has been physically abused would have trouble distinguishing between holding therapy and the abuse they suffered. Other attachment therapies include a focus on developing a bond with the therapist or other caregivers (2004). Play therapy is another method that is used in working with attachment disorder. It teaches the child better ways to cope with stress and also involved “close, comforting bodily contact” (Haugaard & Hazan, 2004).  
While working with the child is important, it is also very important to support and train those surrounding the child to handle their specific therapeutic needs. Sadly most of those who are tasked with parenting these children have no idea what they are dealing with. What is most disturbing is the knowledge that if they were trained to handle the children in their care with sensitivity, patience, and empathetic understanding, the damage could be prevented or lessoned (Cole, 2005).
Cole, 2005 found that foster parents who are trained to handle the special issues related to children in foster care appear to be better able to aid children in the formation of a secure attachment base. When parents are trained in what it takes to promote attachment, they can utilize those actions to help children adjust to the break in attachment and even promote healing (2005).
            There are times when the child will remain in contact with the offending parent. In these cases it is vital that efforts are made to improve the relationship, although the child’s safety should always remain most important (Haugaard & Hazan, 2004). If the goal is reunification, the parent should participate in therapy sessions and perhaps even get counseling for their therapeutic issues. It is unlikely that a psychologically healthy parent would allow their child to end up in circumstances that would lead to removal from the home. Aside from that, a healthy parent is better able to nurture a healthy child.
            There are many interventions within the foster family environment that can aid in the healing and treatment of attachment disorder. While knowledge of the disorder remains paramount, stress in the home can drastically effect whether or not a child heals, or a foster family is able to successfully care for the child (Haugaard & Hazan, 2004). Foster families who are well cared for are better able to care for the children in their home (Haugaard & Hazan, 2004).
Conclusion
Children within the foster care system have a history of pathogenic care that causes them to be at an increased risk for attachment disorder. Research shows a strong correlation between children in foster care and attachment disorder. This is because the primary cause of attachment disorder is pathogenic care. Children in foster care have experienced this type of environment and have learned behaviors that helped them to survive that once placed into a normal environment cause tremendous upset in their lives.
The providers who work with these children are oftentimes not prepared to handle these children and consequently they are left untreated. Untreated attachment disorder leads to children growing up with lifelong maladaptive behaviors that range in severity from mild to life ending. Further research into diagnosis and treatment is needed to develop a single and comprehensive assessment tool for attachment disorder as well as determine a treatment model that can effectively treat our societies most vulnerable children.
 References
Ainsworth, M. S. (1989). Attachments beyond infancy. American Psychologist, 44(4), 709-716. doi:10.1037/0003-066X.44.4.709
Chapman, S. (2002). Reactive attachment disorder. British Journal Of Special Education, 29(2), 91.
Child Welfare Information Center. (2010). Foster Care Statistics. http://www.childwelfare.gov/pubs/factsheets/foster.cfm. Retrieved March, 1, 2013.
Cole, S. (2005). Foster caregiver motivation and infant attachment: How do reasons for fostering affect relationships? Child and Adolescent Social Work Journal, 25(5-6), 441-457.
Connors, M. E., (2011) Attachment theory: A “secure base” for psychotherapy integration. Journal of Psychotherapy Integration, 21(3), Sep 2011, 348-362. doi: 10.1037/a0025460
Feldman, R. (2011). Development Across the Life Span (6th ed.). Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson.
Goldman, J., Salus, M. K., Wolcott, D., Kennedy, K. Y. (2003). Office on Child Abuse and Neglect. A Coordinated Response to Child Abuse and Neglect: The Foundation for Practice. Retrived March 2, 2013 from https://www.childwelfare.gov/pubs/usermanuals/foundation/foundationm.cfm#psychologicalmaltreatment
Greenberg, M. (1999). Attachment and psychopathology in childhood. In Cassidy, J., & Shaver, P. (Eds.), Handbook of Attachment: Theory, research, and clinical applications. (pp. 469-496). New York: Guilford Press.
Hall, S. E. K., & Geher, G. (2003). Behavioral and personality characteristics of children with reactive attachment disorder. The Journal of Psychology, 137(2), 145-62.
Hardy, L. T. (2007), Attachment Theory and Reactive Attachment Disorder: Theoretical Perspectives and Treatment Implications. Journal of Child and Adolescent Psychiatric Nursing, 20: 27–39. doi: 10.1111/j.1744-6171.2007.00077.x
Haugaard, J. & Hazan, C., (2004) Recognizing and Treating Uncommon Behavioral and Emotional Disorders in Children and Adolescents Who Have Been Severely Maltreated: Reactive Attachment Disorder. Child Maltreatment, Vol 9(2), May 2004. pp. 154-160.
Inge, B., (1992) The origins of attachment theory: John Bowlby and Mary Ainsworth.
Developmental Psychology, Vol 28(5), Sep 1992, 759-775. doi: 10.1037/0012-1649.28.5.759
John, P. K., & Kytja, K. S. V. (2008). Reactive attachment disorder in adolescence.  Adolescent Psychiatry, 30, 159-XV. Retrieved from http://search.proquest.com/docview/206091704?accountid=12085
Johnson, C. F. (2004). Child sexual abuse. The Lancet, 364(9432), 462-70. Retrieved I from http://search.proquest.com/docview/199003156?accountid=12085
Sheperis, C. J., Doggett, R., Hoda, N. E., Blanchard, T., Renfro-Michel, E. L., Holdiness, S. H., & Schlagheck, R. (2003). The Development of an Assessment Protocol for Reactive Attachment Disorder. Journal Of Mental Health Counseling, 25(4), 291
Thomas, N. (2005). When love is not enough. A guide to parenting children with reactive attachment disorder. Glenwood Springs, CO: Families By Design.
Vacca, J. (2007). Foster children need more help after they reach the age of eighteen, Children and Youth Services Review, 30(5). May 2008, Pages 485-492, ISSN 0190-7409, 10.1016/j.childyouth.2007.11.007.
(http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0190740907002149)

"What Is Attachment?" Attachment Disorder Site - Providing Hope and Support. N.p., n.d. Web. 28 Jan. 2013.

The Basket Theory

Abstract

This paper addresses my personal therapeutic approach that is an integrated model combining both my Christian beliefs and those aspects of psychology which I think give a clearer explanation of the principles found within God's Word. This combination theory, as the fibers of a basket interwoven together is consistent with my values and beliefs. The following topics  cover the importance of understanding human personality, where problems are developed, how to source problems and structure effective intervention, and how my worldview influences my theory. It will also include how previous theorist’s work has influenced my own thoughts. The paper will conclude with a summary of why I feel this counseling approach best suits my skills, abilities, and personality but most importantly my beliefs.
The Basket Theory
Human value is priceless, “For you know that it was not with perishable things such as silver or gold that you were redeemed…but with the precious blood of Christ, a lamb without blemish or defect” (1 Peter 1:18, NIV). With this in mind, the Christian counselor understands the beauty and value of God’s work. For this reason, it is altogether fitting that one’s ministry would be seek to understand the human personality and what is necessary to maintain mental and spiritual health. Within this paper and approach to Christian counseling the author will attempt to address the  the following: a delineation of personality structure; an explanation of motivation; a description of human development; an accounting for individual differences; a definition of health; a definition of illness; a definition of the elements in a comprehensive theory of cure; a development of the techniques that govern/guide the therapeutic process; a demonstration of effectiveness; and an explanation of how the overall theory relates to a comprehensive Christian worldview. Each of these subjects will be explained by using a basket analogy by comparing the parts of a personality and the outside forces that affect personality to those within and without a basket.
Theory of Personality
The human personality begins with the construction of the basket. One must start with the physical fibers of the basket, as in, what was used to create it. The fibers of the basket would be comprised of the genetics of the parents, and their ability to put the basket together. This forms the basis of one’s personality and sets the stage for how all other influences in ones life will be perceived.  Many other theorists point to the importance of parents in the formation of personality. In particular, Wilson (2001) referred to our parents as gods as they are the ones in ultimate control of everything we know, feel, and see as children. They provide a lens from which we will forever see the world. A well formed basket will have strong fibers woven together in a way that they can withstand whatever weights the world adds to the basket. A basket that is put together poorly starts a humans life with a weakness that will forever affect how a person perceives the world and interacts with it.
Personality is the compilation of who God is, who we are, and how we allow Him to direct our steps. Theorist Crabb defined this further by saying, “The body belongs to the physical side and the spirit and soul to the personal” (Crabb, 1977, p.88). The human personality can be affected by outside factors, sin nature, influence of the holy spirit, feelings, will, thoughts, temporal systems, and supernatural systems. (Hawkins, 2008) Each of these factors put pressure on the fibers of the basket either by pressing from outside, or by adding weight that must be carried. For this reason, it is vital that a person find balance as described by Hart (1999). If one allows those outside influences to damage or overwhelm either the basket’s fibers or their ability to carry a particular weight limit, then one ends up with damage which presents itself in maladaptive thoughts and behaviors as well as spiritual illness.
Theory of Motivation
We are motivated by our perception of ourselves and the world around us, but also by what we believe to be permanent or changeable.
It is not…events either past or present which make us feel the way we feel, but our interpretation of those events. Our feelings are not caused by the circumstances of our long-lost childhood or the circumstances of the present. Our feelings are caused by what we tell ourselves about our circumstances, whether in words or in attitudes” (Backus & Chapian, 2000, p. 17).
Problems arise when one has a skewed view of the world around them, caused oftentimes by the initial poor construction of the basket we carry. Our interpretations can be misguided. This can cause one to lack motivation, feeling that their circumstances are beyond God’s reach. “Satan’s first and foremost strategy is deception” (Anderson, 2000, p. 23).  However, as Christian counselors, we know that the arm of the Lord is never too short. By changing the perception of the world or our clients circumstances, we may revive within them the motivation necessary to make changes that will bring about spiritual and psychological health.
Theory of Human Development and Individual Differences
The bible is clear that humans were created by God. Psalms 139:13-14 states, “For you created my inmost being; you knit me together in my mother’s womb. I praise you because I am fearfully and wonderfully made” (Psalms, NIV) Our lives begin with our earliest experiences and are deeply affected by them later. Early choices made by those in control of us, and the choices we made the survive those choices define and outline our growth. (Wilson, 2001) As adults we can choose to rewrite our mindset, to repair the damage caused to our framework with both hard work and God’s grace. A person may respond positively or negatively to the changes around them as they go through development.
If we are all designed by the same Creator, it seems that we would all be, think, and feel the same. However, this is not so. Not only are differences caused because each of us experiences unique circumstances, but also because of our perception of those circumstances. Each of us started with one creator, God, who then allowed people to help weave together who it is we are. We are different because those who were “god to us” are different and our perception of the world, and subsequent thoughts, feelings and actions were framed by them. (Wilson, 2001)
Definition of Health
Health is defined as those people who successfully carry the basket they possess regardless of the circumstances around them, who depend on God first for the strength and wisdom to do so, and who seek assistance when they find an area of lacking in the structure of their basket or their ability to carry it. They have effective boundaries (Cloud & Townsend, 1999) which allow them the protection needed to ensure damage is lessoned or prevented altogether. Self-care is vital to living healthy and requires not only dedication and perseverance, but also the understanding that, “God did not give us a spirit of timidity, but a spirit of power, of love and of self-discipline.” (2 Timothy 1:7) Hart (1999) discusses the importance of rest at length in his book stating that, “Taking time to rest has implications that benefit our minds and our bodies. Resting also affects our relationships and spirituality” (Hart, p. 120). By practicing self care, one is able to live their life to the fullness which God designed.
Definition of Illness
Illness is defined as when there is a separation of who God says we are and who we believe we are. Illness is highlighted by feelings of depression, anxiety, and harm to self and others. In essence, illness comes from misbeliefs. They are the cause of emotional turmoil, maladaptive behavior and mental illness (Backus & Chapian, p. 17).
            Personality is affected by outside factors, sin nature, influence of the Holy Spirit, feelings, will, thoughts, temporal systems, and supernatural systems. (Hawkins, 2008) Each of these factors place pressure on the fibers of the basket either by pressing from outside, or by adding weight that must be carried. For this reason it is vital that a person find balance as described by Hart (1999). If one allows those outside influences to damage or overwhelm either the basket’s fibers or their ability to carry a particular weight limit, then one ends up with damage which presents itself in maladaptive thoughts and behaviors as well as spiritual illness.
Anxiety  is fear in the absence of real danger, an over estimation of danger, or imagined negative results. (Backus & Chapian, 2000).
Psychological illness may also be caused by genetics or the make up of the basket a person carries. In this case it is then the counselors job to help the client make repairs necessary to their basket which may include medication, much the same as you would apply oils to worn rope or fibers.
Role of Integration and Multitasking
While God is the center and sufficient, He gives others the wisdom to provide treatment both in and out of the Christian arena. In the same way we seek a builder to build our home, we seek humans to help rebuild damaged baskets.  Christ has given us a guide from which to build our spirit and mind in a way that is able to carry the weights we will encounter.
           Development of a theory should reflect the ability to multi-task. Multitasking requires that the counselor views “a person’s problems form several perspectives at the same time.” (Hawkins) This means that as clinicians an effort must be made to include a well rounded approach to the clients health.
How to Source Problems and Structure Effective Intervention
God and/or Godly principles must be the basis for any action or thought of both the counselor and counselee. By starting with a firm foundation of God’s word, it is then possible to build upon it, to make repairs when necessary, and to train the client to carry the basket they have been given, regardless of size or circumstance. When a client learns how to care for their basket and carry it properly, they will live in a spiritually mature and healthy manner.
Process and Techniques
In order to facilitate positive change, four interrelated components of counseling are necessary.
The best way to combat temptation is to name satan’s lies and hold onto God’s truth. In order to most effectively bring about change, it is essential that we get our clients to see the truth about themselves and their lives. Without the truth, all other work is meaningless. Wilson admonishes her readers to follow Paul's guidance in 1 Corinthians 11:13 which states, “When I was a child, I talked like a child, I thought like a child, I reasoned like a child. When I became a man, I put the ways of childhood behind me.” (New International Version). According to Wilson, as we become adults, we must somehow change the ideas about ourselves and the world around us that we developed due to our childhood experiences. We must put away old thinking in order to become new creatures.
By locating and identifying the misbeliefs in their lives, a person can then argue against those misbeliefs, and finally replace them with the truth. (Wilson, 2001) By recognizing who they are in God, it is possible to “be the dynamic, loving, altogether whole people God meant us to be”. (Wilson, p.182) By changing those beliefs, we are able to change the cycle of hurt and fulfill the ultimate purpose God has for our lives. The challenge must be made from within. The client must learn to listen to themselves and begin to tell themselves the truth. This allows for healing. (Backus & Chapian, 2000).
Expectations of Effectiveness
An important truth is that “God will never allow a situation to develop in any believer’s life to which he cannot respond biblically” (Crabb, 1977, p. 26). By teaching the clients what the truth is, and encouraging them to practice it, and put it in place within their lives, it is expected that there will be effective change for the better. By lining up counseling methods and theories with God’s word, the counselor ensures the most probable success as God’s word is sufficient (Adams, 1986)
How does my Worldview influence my Theory?
As a Christian, it is vital that all ideas and concepts are filtered thoroughly through God’s word and that the principles within that word are applied. “I am the Alpha and the Omega,’ says the Lord God, ‘who is, and who was, and who is to come, the Almighty’” (Revelation 1:8). Del Thackett, quotes David Noebel's book Understanding the Times, saying a world view is “any ideology, philosophy, theology, movement, or religion that provides an overarching approach to understanding God, the world, and man's relations to God and the world.” (Thackett)
Approach to Integration
God placed us in an interactive world in which we are many times forced to be dependent on others. Throughout history, there have been many examples of God instructing His people to use what was secular to further His purpose. It is the authors belief that there is no difference in therapeutic measures. Crabb discusses this calling it, “Spoiling the Egyptians,” which is in reference to when the Israelites left Egypt they were encouraged to take whatever they wished (Crabb, 1977, p. 47). This is something that must be done with balance and great care. It is vital that those things are carried by the basket, rather than becoming part of the fibers of the basket. If one were to weave different types of fibers that were not tested throughout the basket, it would in effect weaken the basket and lead to illness.
Conclusion
The construction of a Godly and healthy basket requires that a person takes the fibers of our basket and weave them together in a way that God instructs, and then carry that basket in a way God’s principles admonish us to do, and we will have a person who is both spiritually mature and mentally healthy. They will be able to further God’s kingdom and bring about His purposes.  As Christians we have hope because regardless of original circumstances, Romans 8:28 says, “And we know that in all things God works for the good of those who love him.” He will take whatever mess of a basket we have and repair it, or show us how to repair it, if we are only willing. We can use this hope to help those we have the blessing of coming into contact with so that they might not only be healthy, but also come to be one of God’s children.
References
Adams, J. E. (1986). How to help people change. Grand Rapids, MI: Zondervan.
Backus, W., & Chapian, M. (2000). Telling yourself the truth. Bloomington: Bethany House.
Cloud, H., & Townsend, J.  (1999).  Boundaries in marriage.  Grand Rapids, MI: Zondervan
            Publishing House.
Crabb, L. J. Jr., (1977).  Effective Biblical Counseling: A Model for Helping Caring            
Christians Become Capable Counselors.  Grand Rapids, MI: Zondervan Publishing House.
Hart, A. D.  (2001).  The anxiety cure.  Nashville, TN: Thomas Nelson. 
Hawkins, R. E. (Speaker). (2006). Model for guiding the counseling process. Lynchburg, VA:
            Liberty University.
Wilson, S. D.  (2001).  Hurt people hurt people: Hope and healing for yourself and your
 relationships. Grand Rapids, MI: Discovery House Publishers.[A1] 


It is Not Well With My Soul

For months now I have been grieving, from the loss of a sister far away from me to reopened wounds and a general sense of "almost" that never come, I'm tired.

Not the "I need to sleep" kind of tired, but the "what is the point anyway" kind.

Why have a heart for people who closed their hearts to you year ago.

Why make plans for tomorrows when it so easily disappears in todays?

Why learn the lyrics to songs that no one can hear you sing?

For the first time in far longer than I can remember, I don't know anymore.

Yet, I keep doing it, every moment more deliberate than the last.

I keep loving people who will never love me back.

I keep planning as I watch the best laid plans dissolve under this unending rain.

I keep singing aching for someone to hear.

I long for the moment that this internal battle is won either way. At this point I don't care which part wins. I just want to rest.

Tuesday, March 01, 2016

Where I'm From

Where I'm From

Adapted from the original poem by George Ella Lyon


I’m from empty grocery bags from Walmart and being disposable.
I’m from the beautiful chaos of a blended family.
I’m from the mountains, the darkness, the stars that only show up when all light disappears.
I’m from the creativity of the Sutphins, the tenacity of the Freemans, and names recorded in police records instead of bibles.
I am from mistakes and misunderstandings but never giving up.
From, “It’s our little secret” and a God who didn’t see me.
I’m from the Appalachians, soup beans, cornbread, and hobo packs.
From the one time we tied fish to our feet for shoes and other crazy stories we joked about to keep from crying about the truth.
I’m from photos piled in bags left on sidewalks with the trash sorted through in desperation looking for home.
I’m from yesterday, a constant longing for everydays, and dreams of tomorrow.

The Table

 I had such a magic moment this past Christmas. Mali asked to make a gingerbread house so he could eat it, and that’s what we did. As we wor...